Legal principle
When statutory employment rights are in issue, the tribunal must determine the parties' true agreement and practical relationship. Written substitution or self-employment clauses may be disregarded where they do not reflect the reality of how work is performed.
What the court decided
The Supreme Court upheld the finding that car valeters were workers despite written terms describing them as self-employed and containing obligations that did not reflect the practical arrangement.
The practical test
- 1
Examine the written terms and the obligations they appear to create.
- 2
Compare those terms with how the parties actually worked in practice.
- 3
Determine the true agreement, taking account of the worker's relative bargaining position.
How tribunals apply it
- Contract labels such as self-employed are relevant but not decisive.
- A substitution clause with no genuine practical operation may carry little weight.
- Control, personal service and whether the other party is a client or customer remain central statutory questions.
Connected legislation
WorkDisputes tribunal data
Recent decisions involving related issues
These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.
Unpaid Wages
Employer: Team Continuity Solutions Ltd (In Creditors Voluntary Liquidation)
The respondent failed to present a valid response, and the Legal Officer found the holiday pay complaint well-founded, awarding £1,230.00.
Legal Issues (2)
- Unauthorised deduction from wages for holiday pay
- default judgment under rule 22 of the Employment Tribunals Rules of Procedure
Reference: 6024197/2026
Discrimination, Unpaid Wages and Other
Employer: University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust
The claimant succeeded only on the claim for failure to provide written particulars, but received no compensation; all other claims were dismissed.
Legal Issues (3)
- Discrimination under Equality Act 2010
- unauthorised deduction under s.13 Employment Rights Act 1996
- failure to provide written particulars under s.1 Employment Rights Act 1996 and s.38 Employment Act 2002
Reference: 6011494/2024
Unpaid Wages
Employer: Luxe Hospitality Group (NW) Ltd
The complaint of unauthorised deductions was well-founded by consent, and the respondent was ordered to pay £10,380.
Legal Issues (1)
- Unauthorised deductions from wages under Part II of the Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 2401459/2026
Unpaid Wages
Employer: Rubar Coffee Ltd
The complaint of unauthorised deductions from wages was well-founded, and the respondent was ordered to pay the deducted sum.
Legal Issues (1)
- Whether the respondent made unauthorised deductions from the claimant's wages contrary to Part II of the Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 6008893/2026
Redundancy Pay, Unpaid Wages, Breach of Contract and Other
The claimants succeeded on redundancy, notice pay, and holiday pay claims; Mrs Thomson's wages claim was dismissed; the Secretary of State was ordered to pay statutory debts.
Legal Issues (6)
- Employment status
- entitlement to redundancy payments under section 163 and 170 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
- complaint of unauthorised deductions from wages
- breach of contract for notice pay
- holiday pay
- the Secretary of State's liability under section 188 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 2601902/2024
Unpaid Wages
Employer: BFH Services Ltd
The respondent failed to respond, and the tribunal found that unauthorised deductions were made from the claimants' wages, awarding compensation.
Legal Issues (2)
- Unauthorised deductions from wages contrary to Part II of the Employment Rights Act 1996
- default judgment procedure under rule 22
Reference: 2401334/2026
