All leading cases

Employment Appeal Tribunal

Williams v Compair Maxam Ltd

[1982] UKEAT 372_81_2201

The classic guidance on consultation, selection criteria and fair redundancy selection.

redundancy selectionconsultationfair procedure

Legal principle

A reasonable redundancy process usually includes early consultation, fair and objective selection criteria, consistent scoring and consideration of alternative work. The guidance is influential rather than a rigid statutory checklist.

What the court decided

The EAT identified features commonly found in fair redundancy procedures, particularly where a recognised union is involved and employees are selected from a pool.

The practical test

  1. 1

    Was there meaningful consultation while proposals could still change?

  2. 2

    Were the pool and selection criteria reasonable, objective and fairly applied?

  3. 3

    Did the employer take reasonable steps to identify suitable alternative employment?

How tribunals apply it

  • Criteria based solely on subjective manager opinion require careful supporting evidence.
  • Employees should normally understand the basis of selection and have a chance to challenge material errors.
  • Fairness remains fact-specific and is assessed within the range of reasonable responses.

Connected legislation

WorkDisputes tribunal data

These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.

30 Oct 2026
Claimant won

Redundancy Pay

Employer: Axis Logistics Ltd (In Administration) and The Secretary of State for Business and Trade

The First Respondent failed to adequately comply with section 188 TULRCA, and the protective award claims succeeded by consent.

Legal Issues (1)
  • Whether the First Respondent failed to comply with section 188 TULRCA 1992 (duty to consult trade union representatives about proposed redundancies) and whether a protective award should be made

Reference: 1304142/2025

27 Oct 2026
Mixed outcome£5,627.81 awarded

Unfair Dismissal, Redundancy Pay, Unpaid Wages and Breach of Contract

Employer: Gecor Plumbing and Heating Ltd

The claimant's unfair dismissal and redundancy claims were dismissed for lack of qualifying service, but the breach of contract and unlawful deduction from wages claims succeeded with awards.

Legal Issues (3)
  • Whether the claimant had sufficient qualifying service for unfair dismissal and redundancy claims
  • whether the apprenticeship agreement was breached
  • whether wages and holiday pay were unlawfully deducted

Reference: 2501383/2025

20 Oct 2026
Claimant won£11,062.50 awarded

Unfair Dismissal, Redundancy Pay and Unpaid Wages

Employer: Sadler Hairdressing Ltd

The claimant won on all three claims: unfair dismissal (declaration), redundancy payment (£8,062.50), and notice pay (£3,000).

Legal Issues (3)
  • Unfair dismissal (failure to follow any procedure, no fair reason shown)
  • redundancy payment (respondent failed to prove dismissal was not for redundancy)
  • breach of contract for notice pay (entitlement to 12 weeks' notice, only 4 given)

Reference: 2600417/2026

19 Oct 2026
Claimant won

Redundancy Pay

Employer: Hind Wellingborough Ltd (in liquidation) and Secretary of State for Business and Trade

The claim for a protective award succeeded because the first respondent failed to consult with employee representatives before making 20 or more employees redundant.

Legal Issues (5)
  • Failure to consult under section 188 TULR(C)A 1992
  • protective award
  • time limit under section 189(5)(b)
  • maximum period for protective award
  • role of statutory guarantor

Reference: 3301888/2026

16 Oct 2026
Mixed outcome£14,480.39 awarded

Redundancy Pay, Unpaid Wages, Breach of Contract and Other

Employer: Builders Merchant Company Ltd (in Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation) and Secretary of State for Business and Trade

The claimants succeeded on redundancy, notice pay, and holiday pay claims; Mrs Thomson's wages claim was dismissed; the Secretary of State was ordered to pay statutory debts.

Legal Issues (6)
  • Employment status
  • entitlement to redundancy payments under section 163 and 170 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
  • complaint of unauthorised deductions from wages
  • breach of contract for notice pay
  • holiday pay
  • the Secretary of State's liability under section 188 of the Employment Rights Act 1996

Reference: 2601902/2024

15 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Unfair Dismissal and Discrimination

Employer: Princess Yachts Ltd

The tribunal dismissed all claims, finding that the redundancy process was fair and reasonable, that the claimant was not subjected to discrimination or victimisation, and that the duty to make reasonable adjustments did not arise as the removal of weekend working did not place the claimant at a substantial disadvantage compared to non-disabled persons.

Legal Issues (4)
  • Whether the dismissal was fair under section 98(4) of the Employment Rights Act 1996
  • whether the respondent directly discriminated against the claimant because of his disability
  • whether the respondent failed to make reasonable adjustments (specifically regarding the removal of weekend working)
  • whether the claimant was subjected to victimisation for raising grievances about reasonable adjustments

Reference: 6015607/2025