25 Sept 2026
Claim dismissed
Unfair Dismissal
Employer: Drumduan School Ltd
The claimant's unfair dismissal claim was dismissed on the merits because the Tribunal found that the respondent had a genuine and reasonable belief in the claimant's gross misconduct, carried out a reasonable investigation, and acted within the band of reasonable responses in deciding to dismiss.
Legal Issues (6)
- Whether the principal reason for dismissal was conduct (a potentially fair reason under s.98(2) ERA 1996)
- whether the dismissal was fair under s.98(4) ERA 1996 (band of reasonable responses)
- whether the employer had a genuine and reasonable belief in the misconduct after a reasonable investigation
- procedural fairness including suspension
- disclosure of witness statements
- the appeal process
Reference: 8003054/2025
