16 Oct 2026
Claimant won
Unfair Dismissal
Heard at Cambridge
The unfair dismissal complaint succeeded because the respondent's disciplinary process lacked independence, the investigation was inadequate, and dismissal fell outside the range of reasonable responses.
Legal Issues (8)
- The key legal issues were: whether the claim was presented in time
- the reason for dismissal
- whether the respondent had a genuine belief in misconduct
- reasonable grounds
- carried out a reasonable investigation
- whether dismissal fell within the range of reasonable responses
- whether a Polkey reduction should apply
- whether a reduction for contributory conduct should be made
Reference: 6013980/2025
