All leading cases

Court of Appeal

Ishola v Transport for London

[2020] EWCA Civ 112

Clarifies what amounts to a provision, criterion or practice in Equality Act claims.

indirect discriminationprovision criterion or practice

Legal principle

A provision, criterion or practice normally describes a rule, policy, practice or state of affairs with an element of repetition or continuing application. It is not a phrase that automatically covers every one-off act or decision.

What the court decided

The Court of Appeal warned against treating PCP as a catch-all expression. The alleged PCP must be identified clearly enough for group and individual disadvantage to be tested.

The practical test

  1. 1

    State precisely the rule, practice or continuing state of affairs relied upon.

  2. 2

    Show how it was or would be applied beyond the isolated facts of the complaint.

  3. 3

    Connect that PCP to the required disadvantage and, where relevant, justification analysis.

How tribunals apply it

  • A single application of an existing policy may evidence a PCP even though the decision happened once.
  • A purely one-off decision with no element of repetition may not be a PCP.
  • Careful pleading matters because different PCP formulations can produce different disadvantage evidence.

Connected legislation

WorkDisputes tribunal data

These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.

23 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Discrimination, Whistleblowing and Harassment

Employer: The Orchard School

All claims were dismissed as out of time and also as without proper foundation on the merits.

Legal Issues (8)
  • Time limits under the Equality Act 2010 and Employment Rights Act 1996
  • whether discrimination was conduct extending over a period
  • just and equitable extension
  • reasonably practicable test for whistleblowing
  • definition of harassment
  • substantial disadvantage for reasonable adjustments
  • protected acts and causation for victimisation
  • whether the protected disclosure was a material influence on detriments

Reference: 6013579/2024

23 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Unfair Dismissal, Constructive Dismissal, Discrimination and Harassment

Employer: Life Vineyard Church

All of the claimant's complaints were dismissed as not well founded after a full merits hearing.

Legal Issues (5)
  • The key legal issues were whether the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed
  • whether she suffered discrimination constructive dismissal
  • direct disability discrimination
  • harassment related to disability
  • whether the respondent failed to make reasonable adjustments

Reference: 2500671/2024

21 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination, Unpaid Wages and Whistleblowing

Employer: Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust

All claims were dismissed on the merits after a full hearing; the tribunal found none of the alleged acts of discrimination, detriment, unfair dismissal, or wage deductions were established.

Legal Issues (7)
  • Direct and indirect race and disability discrimination
  • victimisation
  • reasonable adjustments
  • protected disclosure detriment
  • automatic and ordinary unfair dismissal
  • constructive dismissal (as part of ordinary unfair dismissal)
  • unauthorised deductions from wages

Reference: 2501714/2023

18 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Discrimination and Whistleblowing

Employer: Hampshire and Isle of Wight Fire and Rescue Authority

All claims were dismissed on the merits after a final hearing.

Legal Issues (7)
  • Direct disability discrimination (Equality Act 2010 section 13)
  • discrimination arising from disability (section 15)
  • victimisation (section 27)
  • protected disclosure detriment (Employment Rights Act 1996 section 47B)
  • time limits and jurisdiction
  • postponement and absence
  • burden of proof

Reference: 6012445/2024

16 Oct 2026
Claim struck out

Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination and Whistleblowing

Employer: Hales Group plc

All claims were struck out under Rule 47 of the Employment Tribunal Rules because the claimant failed to attend hearings and did not show cause for her non-attendance.

Legal Issues (3)
  • Whether claims should be dismissed under Rule 47 of the Employment Tribunal Rules 2024 for non-attendance
  • consideration of available information about reasons for absence
  • the claimant's failure to comply with case management orders and to engage with the tribunal

Reference: 1807089/2025

15 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Unfair Dismissal and Discrimination

Employer: Princess Yachts Ltd

The tribunal dismissed all claims, finding that the redundancy process was fair and reasonable, that the claimant was not subjected to discrimination or victimisation, and that the duty to make reasonable adjustments did not arise as the removal of weekend working did not place the claimant at a substantial disadvantage compared to non-disabled persons.

Legal Issues (4)
  • Whether the dismissal was fair under section 98(4) of the Employment Rights Act 1996
  • whether the respondent directly discriminated against the claimant because of his disability
  • whether the respondent failed to make reasonable adjustments (specifically regarding the removal of weekend working)
  • whether the claimant was subjected to victimisation for raising grievances about reasonable adjustments

Reference: 6015607/2025