Legal principle
There is no rigid divide between conveying information and making an allegation. A statement may do both, but it must have sufficient factual content to be capable of tending to show one of the statutory forms of wrongdoing.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal disapproved treating the word 'allegation' as automatically excluding protection and emphasised the need to read the communication in context.
The practical test
- 1
Identify the words communicated and their surrounding context.
- 2
Ask what factual information, if any, the communication conveyed.
- 3
Decide whether that information was capable of tending to show relevant wrongdoing.
How tribunals apply it
- Several communications may need to be read together.
- A bare assertion with no factual content may be insufficient.
- The disclosure does not need to prove wrongdoing, but the statutory reasonable-belief requirements still apply.
Connected legislation
WorkDisputes tribunal data
Recent decisions involving related issues
These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.
Unfair Dismissal and Whistleblowing
Employer: NR Education Ltd T/a Infiniti School and Ms A Daly
The claimant succeeded on all claims of unfair dismissal and whistleblowing detriment.
Legal Issues (3)
- Ordinary unfair dismissal
- automatically unfair dismissal under section 103A Employment Rights Act 1996 for whistleblowing
- detriment for protected disclosures
Reference: 6014102/2025
Discrimination, Whistleblowing and Harassment
Employer: Betsi Cadwaladr University Local Health Board
All claims of discrimination, harassment, victimisation and whistleblowing detriment were dismissed on the merits after a full hearing.
Legal Issues (4)
- Race and religion discrimination
- harassment
- victimisation
- protected disclosure detriment under the Equality Act 2010 and Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 1601283/2024
Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination and Whistleblowing
Employer: First Choice Medical Care and A Nizamuddin
The claimant's constructive unfair dismissal claim succeeded, but her discrimination and whistleblowing claims were dismissed as out of time.
Legal Issues (4)
- Time limits for discrimination and whistleblowing claims
- constructive dismissal
- breach of implied term of trust and confidence
- reasonableness of employer's conduct
Reference: 3303588/2024
Discrimination, Whistleblowing and Harassment
Employer: The Orchard School
All claims were dismissed as out of time and also as without proper foundation on the merits.
Legal Issues (8)
- Time limits under the Equality Act 2010 and Employment Rights Act 1996
- whether discrimination was conduct extending over a period
- just and equitable extension
- reasonably practicable test for whistleblowing
- definition of harassment
- substantial disadvantage for reasonable adjustments
- protected acts and causation for victimisation
- whether the protected disclosure was a material influence on detriments
Reference: 6013579/2024
Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination, Unpaid Wages, Whistleblowing and Harassment
Employer: Royal Borough of Greenwich
The tribunal found that the claim for unauthorised deduction of wages succeeded, but all other claims (constructive unfair dismissal, discrimination, harassment, victimisation, whistleblowing) failed on liability.
Legal Issues (11)
- Key legal points include: whether the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed
- whether there was direct/indirect discrimination
- discrimination arising from disability
- failure to make reasonable adjustments
- harassment
- victimisation
- detriment for health and safety disclosures
- whether the respondent was entitled to place the claimant on sick pay during medical suspension
- whether the unauthorised deduction claim succeeded. The tribunal found that the respondent was not entitled to treat the claimant as falling within scenario 1 (unwell) for sick pay purposes
- that the claimant should have been on full pay during suspension
- leading to a successful unauthorised deduction claim
Reference: 2303101/2022
Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination, Unpaid Wages and Whistleblowing
Employer: Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust
All claims were dismissed on the merits after a full hearing; the tribunal found none of the alleged acts of discrimination, detriment, unfair dismissal, or wage deductions were established.
Legal Issues (7)
- Direct and indirect race and disability discrimination
- victimisation
- reasonable adjustments
- protected disclosure detriment
- automatic and ordinary unfair dismissal
- constructive dismissal (as part of ordinary unfair dismissal)
- unauthorised deductions from wages
Reference: 2501714/2023
