All leading cases

House of Lords

Shamoon v Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary

[2003] UKHL 11

A leading discrimination authority on detriment, comparators and identifying why treatment occurred.

discriminationdetrimentcomparator

Legal principle

A detriment exists where a reasonable worker would or might take the view that the treatment disadvantaged them. In direct discrimination, tribunals often find it clearer to ask why the claimant was treated as they were rather than becoming trapped in an artificial comparator exercise.

What the court decided

The House of Lords explained that the comparator and reason-why questions are tools for identifying discriminatory treatment, not rigid exercises detached from the evidence.

The practical test

  1. 1

    Identify the treatment and whether it could reasonably be viewed as a disadvantage.

  2. 2

    Determine the reason why the respondent treated the claimant that way.

  3. 3

    Use an actual or hypothetical comparator whose material circumstances are the same where comparison assists.

How tribunals apply it

  • An unjustified sense of grievance alone is insufficient, but financial loss is not required.
  • The circumstances relevant to a comparator depend on the reason for the treatment in issue.
  • Evidence about the decision maker's reasoning is usually central.

Connected legislation

WorkDisputes tribunal data

These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.

26 Oct 2026
Mixed outcome

Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination and Whistleblowing

Employer: First Choice Medical Care and A Nizamuddin

The claimant's constructive unfair dismissal claim succeeded, but her discrimination and whistleblowing claims were dismissed as out of time.

Legal Issues (4)
  • Time limits for discrimination and whistleblowing claims
  • constructive dismissal
  • breach of implied term of trust and confidence
  • reasonableness of employer's conduct

Reference: 3303588/2024

23 Oct 2026
Mixed outcome

Unfair Dismissal, Discrimination, Unpaid Wages, Whistleblowing and Harassment

Employer: Royal Borough of Greenwich

The tribunal found that the claim for unauthorised deduction of wages succeeded, but all other claims (constructive unfair dismissal, discrimination, harassment, victimisation, whistleblowing) failed on liability.

Legal Issues (11)
  • Key legal points include: whether the claimant was constructively unfairly dismissed
  • whether there was direct/indirect discrimination
  • discrimination arising from disability
  • failure to make reasonable adjustments
  • harassment
  • victimisation
  • detriment for health and safety disclosures
  • whether the respondent was entitled to place the claimant on sick pay during medical suspension
  • whether the unauthorised deduction claim succeeded. The tribunal found that the respondent was not entitled to treat the claimant as falling within scenario 1 (unwell) for sick pay purposes
  • that the claimant should have been on full pay during suspension
  • leading to a successful unauthorised deduction claim

Reference: 2303101/2022

22 Oct 2026
Claim dismissed

Discrimination

Employer: East Sussex County Council

All discrimination claims were dismissed on the merits as the Tribunal found that the Respondent's actions were proportionate and not discriminatory.

Legal Issues (6)
  • Discrimination arising from disability (s15 EqA)
  • indirect disability discrimination (s19 EqA)
  • failure to make reasonable adjustments (s20/21 EqA). Key issues: whether unfavourable treatment arose in consequence of disability
  • whether treatment was proportionate
  • whether a PCP placed the Claimant at a substantial disadvantage
  • whether reasonable steps were taken

Reference: 6013225/2024

22 Oct 2026
Mixed outcome

Discrimination, Unpaid Wages and Other

Employer: University Hospitals Sussex NHS Foundation Trust

The claimant succeeded only on the claim for failure to provide written particulars, but received no compensation; all other claims were dismissed.

Legal Issues (3)
  • Discrimination under Equality Act 2010
  • unauthorised deduction under s.13 Employment Rights Act 1996
  • failure to provide written particulars under s.1 Employment Rights Act 1996 and s.38 Employment Act 2002

Reference: 6011494/2024

22 Oct 2026
Partial decision

Discrimination and Harassment

Employer: Santa Maria Novella UK Ltd

The Tribunal dismissed the direct race discrimination and direct sexual orientation discrimination claims as out of time, but allowed the harassment related to sex claim to proceed by extending the time limit.

Legal Issues (2)
  • Whether the claims were presented within the applicable time limit
  • whether it is just and equitable to extend time for each complaint

Reference: 6001552/2025

14 Oct 2026
Claim struck out

Discrimination and Harassment

Employer: Bridge-it Housing UK Team Ltd

The claim was struck out because, after the amendment application was refused, no arguable discrimination or harassment complaints with reasonable prospects of success remained.

Legal Issues (3)
  • Amendment application
  • whether remaining complaints had reasonable prospects of success
  • strike-out of claims with no reasonable prospect of success

Reference: 6018828/2024