Legal principle
When reviewing a misconduct dismissal, the tribunal must ask whether the investigation fell within the range of investigations a reasonable employer could have carried out. It should not replace the employer's investigation with the investigation it would have preferred.
What the court decided
The Court of Appeal confirmed that the statutory reasonableness test applies to the whole disciplinary process, including the scope and depth of the investigation.
The practical test
- 1
Identify the enquiries the employer made before deciding the allegations.
- 2
Assess whether those enquiries were within the range open to a reasonable employer.
- 3
Keep the investigation question separate from whether the tribunal itself believes the allegation.
How tribunals apply it
- An employer need not pursue every possible line of enquiry, but must investigate points that could materially affect the decision.
- Ignoring readily available evidence may take an investigation outside the reasonable range.
- The required investigation depends on the seriousness of the allegation and its likely consequences.
Connected legislation
WorkDisputes tribunal data
Recent decisions involving related issues
These decisions are selected from topic classifications in our public Employment Tribunal dataset. A matching topic does not mean the decision applied this authority directly.
Unfair Dismissal
Employer: Proxymity Ltd
The unfair dismissal complaint was struck out because the claimant had less than two years' service and failed to provide an acceptable reason for the claim to proceed.
Legal Issues (1)
- Whether the claimant had sufficient qualifying service (two years) to bring an unfair dismissal complaint under section 108 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 6000812/2026
Unfair Dismissal
Employer: GXO Logistics UK Ltd
The Tribunal found the claimant's unfair dismissal complaint well-founded, with remedy to be determined at a further hearing.
Legal Issues (4)
- Unfair dismissal under section 94 ERA
- Polkey reduction
- contributory fault
- ACAS Code compliance
Reference: 6016823/2025
Unfair Dismissal and Whistleblowing
Employer: NR Education Ltd T/a Infiniti School and Ms A Daly
The claimant succeeded on all claims of unfair dismissal and whistleblowing detriment.
Legal Issues (3)
- Ordinary unfair dismissal
- automatically unfair dismissal under section 103A Employment Rights Act 1996 for whistleblowing
- detriment for protected disclosures
Reference: 6014102/2025
Unfair Dismissal and Discrimination
Employer: Stark Building Materials UK Ltd
The entire claim was dismissed because the claimant lacked the necessary continuous employment for unfair dismissal and the race discrimination claims were out of time.
Legal Issues (1)
- Jurisdictional requirements for unfair dismissal (2 years continuous employment) and time limits for discrimination claims
Reference: 6010503/2026
Unfair Dismissal
Employer: Watches of Switzerland Operations Ltd
The claim was dismissed because it was not presented within the statutory time limit.
Legal Issues (1)
- Time limit for presenting unfair dismissal claim under section 111 of the Employment Rights Act 1996
Reference: 6003930/2025
Unfair Dismissal, Redundancy Pay, Unpaid Wages and Breach of Contract
Employer: Gecor Plumbing and Heating Ltd
The claimant's unfair dismissal and redundancy claims were dismissed for lack of qualifying service, but the breach of contract and unlawful deduction from wages claims succeeded with awards.
Legal Issues (3)
- Whether the claimant had sufficient qualifying service for unfair dismissal and redundancy claims
- whether the apprenticeship agreement was breached
- whether wages and holiday pay were unlawfully deducted
Reference: 2501383/2025
