The claimant's claims of disability discrimination, failure to make reasonable adjustments, harassment and victimisation were not well founded and were dismissed.
Legal Issues (6)
Disability discrimination
reasonable adjustments
harassment
victimisation
burden of proof
whether the respondent's actions were unfavourable treatment arising from disability
The claimant won on ordinary unfair dismissal but received no compensatory award because he would have been fairly dismissed anyway, and the basic award was reduced to nil by contributory fault (the judgment states a 50% reduction but does not quantify the basic award, so total compensation is effectively zero).
Legal Issues (5)
Ordinary unfair dismissal under s98 Employment Rights Act 1996
automatic unfair dismissal under s103A (protected disclosure) not permitted to be added
reduction of basic award for contributory fault
compensatory award reduced to nil due to inevitable fair dismissal
withdrawal of breach of contract and holiday pay claims
The tribunal found that the pay progression was not a contractual entitlement but was subject to negotiation with the CWU, and the claimants had reached the top of their salary band, so no unauthorised deductions occurred.
Legal Issues (3)
Whether the pay progression was a contractual entitlement or subject to collective bargaining
whether the claimants had reached the top of their pay band
whether the claim was for an unquantifiable sum and thus outside the tribunal's jurisdiction